In 1976, the U.S. marked its 200th birthday with a unique redesign of the quarter. Replacing the classic eagle, the reverse displayed a Colonial Drummer Boy, symbolizing patriotism and the Revolutionary War era. These quarters were mass-produced by the Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco Mints, including special 40% silver issues for collectors. Yet, among the millions made, a few rare examples, minting mistakes, and pristine coins have become prized items for collectors.
Why Are Some Bicentennial Quarters So Valuable?
A few major factors determine a Bicentennial Quarter’s value:
Mint Errors: Production flaws such as doubled dies, off-center strikes, or missing clad layers can turn an ordinary coin into a rare collectible.
Silver Composition: While most are copper-nickel, a limited number were minted in 40% silver, increasing their appeal and intrinsic value.
Condition: Coins in excellent condition, especially uncirculated and proof versions, tend to command much higher prices.
Rarity and Demand: Scarce variations or errors that are in demand by collectors are much more valuable than typical coins.
Top Bicentennial Quarter Varieties That Are Highly Valuable
1. 1976-S Silver Bicentennial Quarter Business Strike
George Washington originally resisted the idea of his likeness on currency, viewing it as too monarchical. He and Benjamin Franklin supported liberty-themed imagery instead, hence the use of Lady Liberty on early coins. Over time, Liberty was modeled after real women:
- Elsie Stevens – Mercury Dime
- Teresa de Francisci – Peace Dollar
- Ann Willing Bingham – Draped Bust Coinage
The 1976-S Silver Business Strike Quarter is among the rarest finds:
- Composition: 40% Silver
- Mint: San Francisco
- Grade: MS69
- Sale Date: June 9, 2019
- Price: $19,200
This coin blends America’s early symbolism with modern historic recognition.
2. 1976-S Silver Proof Bicentennial Quarter
Auction Price: $13,500 • Grade: PR25 • Date: March 26, 2019
A standout collectible is the 1976-S Silver Proof Quarter, made of 40% silver at the San Francisco Mint. By the 1970s, the U.S. had replaced silver coins with clad compositions due to the 1960s coin shortage. However, these silver-clad editions were produced as collector’s items, making them rare and sought after.
3. 1976-S Bicentennial Quarter Double Struck on Dime – PR67 Cameo
Auction Price: $12,000 • Grade: PR67 • Date: 2021
This rare mint error was mistakenly struck on a clad dime twice:
- Double Denomination Error: Quarter design stamped on a dime
- Second Strike Rotation: 100 degrees off-center
- Visual Details: You can see traces of both the original dime and the over-struck quarter
- Grading: PR67 Cameo by PCGS
This is likely a one-of-a-kind mistake, making it incredibly rare.
4. 1976-S Clad Proof Bicentennial Quarter
Auction Price: $6,038 • Date: November 3, 2010
This collector’s proof coin features a mirror finish and was produced at the San Francisco Mint. While many are still in original sets, those in top condition—like the $6,038 example—are extremely valuable.
5. 1976 Clad Bicentennial Quarter Regular Strike
Auction Price: $2,520 • Grade: MS64 • Date: August 18, 2024
With its famous Drummer Boy design, this clad version was made for circulation. Though common, a pristine MS64 specimen sold for $2,520, proving that condition makes a big difference in value.
How to Spot a Valuable Bicentennial Quarter
Want to see if your coin is worth more than face value? Try these steps:
- Mint Mark Check: Look for an “S” mark—this often means it’s a silver proof quarter.
- Error Inspection: Use a magnifier to find double strikes, off-centers, or missing layers.
- Condition Review: Glossy, uncirculated, or proof coins are far more desirable.
- Get Expert Advice: For anything unusual or high quality, get a professional coin appraisal or grading service opinion.
Even though most Bicentennial Quarters are only worth 25 cents, knowing what to look for might uncover a rare and valuable find in your pocket change. Happy hunting!
FAQs
How can I tell if my Bicentennial Quarter is silver?
Check for an “S” mint mark and weigh the coin; silver quarters are heavier than standard clad ones.
Are Bicentennial Quarters still in circulation today?
Yes, many remain in circulation, though most found today are common clad versions with little added value.
What is the difference between a proof and regular strike coin?
Proof coins have a polished, mirror-like finish and are made for collectors, while regular strikes are for circulation.
Is it worth getting my Bicentennial Quarter graded?
If it has a mint error or appears in uncirculated condition, grading could increase its market value significantly.