Presidential dollar coins may not always command the spotlight, but certain rare versions are highly valuable to collectors. While these coins were originally minted for everyday circulation, a variety of factors—such as minting errors, limited production, and unique features—have made select coins incredibly sought-after.
Whether you’re a seasoned numismatist or just beginning your collection, learning about the most prized Presidential dollar coins could help you uncover hidden gems. In this guide, we’ll highlight the top 10 Presidential dollar coins that stand out due to their rarity and impressive market values.
The Most Valuable Presidential Dollar Coins
Are Presidential dollar coins really worth more than a dollar? Below, we dive into the most collectible and valuable coins in the series and what makes them special.
1. 2007-D George Washington Dollar, First Day of Issue, MS67
Though minted in large quantities, some 2007-D George Washington dollars carry extra value, especially those marked as “First Day of Issue” (FDI). To qualify for this designation, coins must be submitted to professional grading services like PCGS or NGC on the official release date—February 15, 2007.
While over 163 million coins were produced in Denver and 176 million in Philadelphia, making them common, only two have been graded MS67 by PCGS. These rare specimens command a significant premium, with one fetching $228 on eBay in 2012, and now estimated at $475 by PCGS.
2. (2007) George Washington Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS68
In 2007, some Washington dollars were mistakenly released without the edge lettering, including the mint mark and motto “In God We Trust.” This error led to the nickname “Godless Dollars.” Initial sales were high, and in 2010, a coin graded MS67 sold for $1,007.
As more examples surfaced, prices fell. Today, PCGS values an MS67 coin at $260, but three MS68 examples exist and are appraised at a remarkable $4,250 each.
3. (2007) Thomas Jefferson Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS68
Another 2007 error coin honors Thomas Jefferson and also lacks the expected edge inscriptions. Early on, values soared, with an MS66 coin selling for $1,725 in 2009. However, over 700 coins at that grade now exist, and they’re valued at just over $100 each.
The standout is a single MS68 specimen, the finest known, which PCGS values at $6,500.
4. (2007) James Madison Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS67
James Madison’s 2007 dollar coin also experienced the missing edge lettering error. Although over 200 million were minted, the error versions remain relatively scarce.
A coin graded MS66 sold for $441 in 2013, with current PCGS value at $600. The finest known MS67 example is appraised at $4,000, though it hasn’t yet sold publicly.
5. (2008) John Quincy Adams Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS68
Though collectors were now used to plain-edge coins, the missing edge lettering on the 2008 John Quincy Adams dollar still drew attention. In 2012, an MS66 specimen sold for $1,104. Today, PCGS values that grade at $200.
Seventeen coins graded MS68 exist, each valued at $425.
6. 2008-D Andrew Jackson Dollar – Position A, MS67
This dollar commemorates the seventh president, Andrew Jackson. The 2008 issue came in two types: Position A and Position B, based on how the edge lettering is oriented.
Position A coins with MS67 grades are the top-tier examples, with only seven certified by PCGS, and each is estimated to be worth $370.
7. (2008) Andrew Jackson Dollar – Satin Finish, Missing Edge Lettering, SP69
Satin finish coins were made for collectors with a finer appearance. A small number of Andrew Jackson dollars in this category were also struck without edge lettering.
While many exist in SP67, just two coins have achieved the near-perfect SP69 grade. Each of these rare pieces is valued at $1,000 by PCGS.
8. 2009-P John Tyler Dollar – Position A, MS68
By 2009, the Presidential dollar series was starting to see lower mintage figures. Only about 87 million John Tyler coins were made. A 2009 Position A coin graded MS67 once sold for $1,150 at auction.
However, as more high-grade examples surfaced, its value dropped to $225. The top-graded MS68 coin now holds a PCGS estimate of $900.
9. (2009) William Henry Harrison Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS69
This 2009 issue honoring President Harrison included some coins missing edge lettering. These error coins in MS63 grade start at around $30, with MS67+ increasing in value to $200.
An MS69 specimen, the best known, sold in 2019 for $456, and was later resold in 2022 for $1,250.
10. (2010) Millard Fillmore Dollar – Missing Edge Lettering, MS69
Struck in 2010, this coin continued the trend of edge lettering errors. While MS65 coins are common (valued around $40), a record auction price of $646 was once set for a coin of that grade.
The best example, graded MS69 and the only one of its kind, has never sold but carries a PCGS valuation of $5,500.
Are Presidential Dollar Coins Valuable?
In general, most Presidential dollars found in circulation are only worth their face value. However, coins in pristine condition—especially those with rare errors or unique finishes—can sell for hundreds or even thousands of dollars.
FAQs
Q1: What makes a Presidential dollar coin valuable?
Rare errors, mint condition, low mintage, and unique designations like “First Day of Issue” can significantly boost a coin’s value.
Q2: Where is the mint mark on a Presidential dollar coin?
The mint mark is located on the coin’s edge and will either be a “D” for Denver or a “P” for Philadelphia.
Q3: Are missing edge lettering Presidential dollars rare?
Yes, while not all are extremely valuable, those in high grades or with special finishes are much rarer and more valuable.
Q4: Can I find valuable Presidential dollar coins in circulation?
It’s possible but uncommon. Most high-value coins are in mint condition or come from special collector sets.